Divorce often necessitates a change in ownership of marital property, especially the family home; choosing the right type of deed is a critical aspect of property settlement. Two common types of deeds that often come up in the context of divorce are Quit Claim Deeds and Warranty Deeds. Each serves a different purpose and offers varying levels of protection and assurance in property transfer. Understanding the differences between these deeds and their implications during a divorce can help divorcing spouses make more informed decisions regarding property ownership.

What Is a Deed?

A deed is a legal document that transfers real estate ownership from one party to another. It is crucial in property transactions because it defines the new owner and ensures the transfer is legally recorded. There are multiple types of deeds, but we will focus on Quit Claim Deeds and Warranty Deeds.

Quit Claim Deed Explained

A Quit Claim Deed (sometimes called "quitclaim") is one of the most straightforward property transfer forms. It allows one party to transfer their interest in a property to another party without any warranties or guarantees about the status of the property title. In other words, the person transferring the property (the grantor) is simply "quitting" any claim they have on the property and transferring it to the new owner (the grantee).

A Quit Claim Deed does not provide any assurance that the title is clear or that there are no other claims against the property. It only transfers whatever interest the grantor may have, if any, at the time of the transfer. This means that if there are any existing liens or title issues, the grantee is receiving them as part of the property transfer.

Quit Claim Deeds are commonly used:

  • Between family members or when there is an existing level of trust.
  • During a divorce, one spouse must transfer their interest in the marital home to the other spouse as part of the property settlement.

Quit Claim Deed in Divorce

A Quit Claim Deed is commonly used in divorce cases because it allows one spouse to quickly and efficiently transfer their interest in the marital home to the other spouse, often without involving a formal sale. This is typically done as part of the divorce settlement, where one party may agree to relinquish their interest in the property in exchange for other assets or considerations.

  • For example, if the wife is awarded the marital home in the divorce, the husband may execute a Quit Claim Deed to transfer his ownership interest to her. This allows the wife to become the sole owner of the property, and the husband is effectively removed from the title.
  • However, it’s important to note that while a Quit Claim Deed transfers ownership, it does not relieve the grantor of any mortgage obligations. If both spouses' names are on the mortgage, they will remain liable for the debt unless the mortgage is refinanced in the sole name of the remaining owner. This is a crucial point to consider, as failing to refinance could result in both parties being responsible for the mortgage, even though only one owns the property.

 

Warranty Deed Explained

A Warranty Deed, in contrast, provides greater protection to the buyer or recipient of the property. When a property is transferred via a Warranty Deed, the grantor makes several guarantees, including a clear and valid title to the property, no liens or encumbrances (unless specified), and the right to transfer ownership.

In effect, the grantor warrants that the property title is free from any defects that could impact the new owner. If there are issues with the title, the grantee may have legal recourse to recover damages from the grantor.

Warranty Deeds are typically used in:

  • Traditional real estate transactions between a buyer and a seller who may not know each other well.
  • Situations where the buyer needs assurance about the quality of the title to secure financing.

Warranty Deed in Divorce

A Warranty Deed is less commonly used in divorce, but it might be appropriate in some scenarios. For instance, if one spouse is "buying out" the other spouse's share of the property, they may prefer to use a Warranty Deed to ensure that there are no undisclosed liens or claims on the property. This provides the buying spouse with protection against any potential title defects.

When the property has been in dispute or there are questions regarding the title, a Warranty Deed may offer more security to the spouse receiving the property. However, because of the warranties involved, this type of transfer is more complex and may require additional steps, such as a title search or title insurance, making it less common in the context of divorce.

Impact of Divorce on Property Ownership and Deed Selection

Divorce can be a complicated and emotional process, especially when it comes to dividing marital assets like real estate. Choosing between a Quit Claim Deed and a Warranty Deed can have significant implications for both parties.

Quit Claim Deed vs. Warranty Deed: Key Differences

  1. Level of Protection:
    • A Quit Claim Deed offers no guarantees about the title; it simply transfers whatever interest the grantor has, if any.
    • A Warranty Deed guarantees that the title is clear and gives the grantee recourse if defects arise.
  2. Use Cases:
    • Quit Claim Deeds are often used between parties that know and trust each other, such as during divorce, between family members, or for clearing up ownership rights.
    • Warranty Deeds are standard for formal real estate transactions, where a buyer needs assurance regarding ownership rights.
  3. Title Assurance:
    • Quit Claim Deeds do not assure that the title is valid, free of liens, or uncontested.
    • Warranty Deeds come with warranties that protect the new owner from title disputes or defects.

Potential Risks and Considerations

When transferring property as part of a divorce settlement, it is essential to understand the potential risks and implications of using a Quit Claim Deed or a Warranty Deed:

  • Title Issues: A Quit Claim Deed does not guarantee that the title is clear. If hidden liens or other claims exist, the spouse receiving the property could be in for an unpleasant surprise. Consulting a title professional or attorney before signing a Quit Claim Deed can help mitigate this risk.
  • Mortgage Liability: Transferring property ownership via a Quit Claim or Warranty Deed does not affect the mortgage. Both parties should work with their lender to determine the best course of action, which often involves refinancing the property into the spouse's name and retaining ownership.
  • Legal Assistance: Divorce-related property transfers can have significant financial and legal consequences. It is highly recommended that both parties work with experienced professionals, including real estate attorneys and Certified Divorce Lending Professionals (CDLPs), to ensure that the property transfer is handled correctly and all potential risks are addressed.

Divorce is a complex process, particularly when real estate is involved. The difference between a Quit Claim Deed and a Warranty Deed plays a crucial role in determining the level of protection for the parties involved. Quit Claim Deeds are most commonly used in divorce settlements due to their simplicity and efficiency in transferring ownership between former spouses. However, they come with potential risks, including unclear title issues and ongoing mortgage liability.

On the other hand, Warranty Deeds offer greater protection to the recipient but are less frequently used in divorce situations because of the warranties involved and the additional steps required. When deciding between these two types of deeds, it’s vital to consider the circumstances, consult professionals, and understand the implications fully.

How Are You Integrating Divorce Mortgage Planning Into Your Case Management?

Involving a Certified Divorce Lending Professional (CDLP®) in the negotiation process opens the door to strategic solutions. A CDLP® can provide clarity and suggested language in the settlement agreement to avoid hiccups with the mortgage loan process when an equity buy-out or new purchase loan is required.

 

This is for informational purposes only and does not provide legal or tax advice. You should contact an attorney or tax professional for legal and tax advice. Interest rates and fees are only estimates provided for informational purposes and are subject to market changes. This is not a commitment to lend. Rates change daily - call for current quotations. 

Copyright —All Rights Divorce Lending Association